EDUC5395

Popular vs. Scholarly vs. Peer-Reviewed

When conducting research, it's important to rely and build upon the work of scholars before you. You'll find research reports in a variety of places: newspapers, academic journals, trade publications and more.

  • Popular - Publications like newspapers and magazines (TIME, Newsweek, etc) are written for the general population. Readers don't need to have expertise to enjoy the articles in these publications. They're written by journalists who aren't necessarily experts on the topic on which they are writing.
  • Peer-Reviewed (or Refereed) - These titles are edited by a panel of experts. For example, Review of Educational Research's editorial board consists of scholars and experts in educational research across the world. In order to be published in these types of publications, writers must themselves be experts and convince their peers they their work deserves publication.
  • Scholarly (or Academic) - Peer-reviewed publications are scholarly, but there are scholarly publications that aren't peer-reviewed. Some titles, like Academic Leadership, are writen by experts, and they are read by experts, but they don't go through the rigorous review process.

Not sure if something is peer-reviewed, scholarly, or popular? Use Ulrich's Periodicals Directory to find out. Search by the journal title, then look for the umpire's uniform to determine if it's "refereed". Click on the title itself to see if it's scholarly.

ulrichs screenshot


Finding Stuff at the UT Arlington Library

Books Pulse, the library catalog
Journal Articles

If you have a bibliographic citation already, use the Find e-Journals tool to locate the article online. If we don't have it online, search for the journal title in Pulse to see if we have it in print.

If you're still looking around, try a subject-specific database or a multidisciplinary database. Check the Education Subject Guide for the names and links to useful databases.

Dissertations ProQuest Dissertations & Theses
Websites

Use these Google tips to help focus your search results:

  • site:*.gov - adding this to the end of your search will limit your results to those websites whose address is from a US Government web site. Replace .gov with .edu to find sites from educational institutions.
  • ~tobacco - the tilday (~) will search for synonyms of the word it preceeds. For this example, Google will find pages about tobacco, cigarettes, cigars, etc.

It's very important to think critically about the websites you use. Is it written by someone who knows their stuff? How sure are you about that?


APA Style


Fun Stuff